Robin's gadri Proposal
John Cowan wrote:
>Robin Lee Powell scripsit:
>
>
>
>>>Then, klama noda is not covered by the meaning of klama, making it a
>>>different selbri.
>>>
>>>
>>One way to look at it, and one which I would be willing to enshrine, is
>>that "klama no da" == "klama zi'o", which is, indeed, a different
>>selbri.
>>
>>
>
>No, that won't work. klama noda is equivalent to klama naku su'oda, which is
>a negative claim (it is about what is not the case), whereas klama zi'o,
>though the x2 has been dropped, is still an affirmative claim (about what
>is the case).
>
>
If that's the case, then it's incorrect to render broda noda --> naku
broda su'oda. Because "noda" surely should not have so dramatic effect
on the other places. Saying that I went lacking a destination is very
different from opening up the possibility that I didn't go at all. We
gain nothing but confusion with such a conflation.
--
Iraq is the second holiest place in Islam. Bin Laden's now got the Americans in the two holiest places in Islam, the Arabian Peninsula and Iraq, and he has the Israelis in Jerusalem. All three sanctities are now occupied by infidels, a great reality for him.