WikiDiscuss

WikiDiscuss


Wiki page How to use xorlo changed

posts: 2388

wrote:

> --- John E Clifford wrote:
> > That is of course a quantifier on a variable,
> not
> > on a description. Are you suddenly going to
> be
> > modular and insist that a quantifier in one
> > context always behaves just like a quantifier
> in
> > another (it won't even work on your system of
> > course)?
>
> PA sumti = PA da poi ke'a me sumti

So you say. I see no reason to think this is
correct (never mind worrying about circularity.

>
> > I note again, of course, that none of this is
> in
> > the offical definitions as given (unless they
> > have changed recently).
>
> It's been there for months, and you have
> commented
> profusely on it, so you can't say you haven't
> seen it
> before.

I meant in either of the pieces called
definitions. The add-ons are another matter entirely.